This is THE perfect recipe for the creamiest mashed potatoes ever! Everyone absolutely raves over them, and we know you will too!
Mashed potatoes are life. Too often we have been subjected to sub-par mashed potatoes, and we do not want that life for you! Perfectly creamy mashed potatoes are worth the effort, and we’re here to hold your hand every step of the way so you can have amazing mashed potatoes every single time. To make perfect mashed potatoes, you need the right proportions of cream cheese, butter, and buttermilk to create the most buttery and delicious mashed potatoes. When the recipe is followed correctly you will end up with perfect, creamy, and delicious mashed potatoes that you will want to eat every single night.
Add-In Options for The Creamiest Mashed Potatoes:
Bacon Mashed Potatoes: Cook between 1/4 to 3/4 pound of bacon until crispy. Replace half the butter in the recipe below with 1/8 cup to 1/4 cup bacon grease.
Cheddar Mashed Potatoes: Add in about 3 cups of shredded cheddar cheese. Then add in 1/4 cup of parsley or chives for some some great tasting cheesy cheddar mashed potatoes.
Other Possible Flavor Additions:
- Dill
- Red bell pepper
- Pesto
- Parmesan cheese
- Italian sausage
- Garlic
Troubleshooting: Lumpy mashed potatoes
If you end up with lumpy mashed potatoes, that probably means the potatoes were undercooked. Simply add a little bit more cream or milk, and cook the potatoes over a low heat until those lumps start to soften. You should be able to mash again to create smooth and creamy mashed potatoes.
Potato Options:
Russet or other high starch potatoes like Yukon golds are the best potatoes to use for mashed potatoes. These high starch potatoes will absorb the flavoring of the butter and cream better, and end up more fluffy and velvety smooth. That being said, you can use red potatoes or types of white potatoes, but they will require more mashing to become creamy, and may be a bit more gummy.
For an Extra Indulgent Treat:
On special occasions like Thanksgiving, where calories and fat are plentiful, I like to double the cream cheese and butter for an extra special creamy treat.
Chef’s Note: After being cooked, these mashed potatoes can be placed in a crockpot on the low or warm setting for up to 4 hours before serving. This comes in quite handy for large and demanding meals like Thanksgiving, Christmas, or Easter.
Why chicken broth?
Your potatoes will absorb some of the liquid that they are cooked in. Cooking your potatoes in chicken broth infuses your potatoes with flavor. You can use homemade chicken stock, chicken broth, bouillon cubes, or better than bouillon. For a vegetarian option, use vegetable stock. When draining the potatoes, you can reserve the broth for a potato soup, but just remember that the broth will be very starchy.
Storage and Reheating Instructions:
Store any leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. Reheat individual servings in the microwave in 30-second increments until warmed through.
If you like this recipe, you may be interested in these other delicious potato side dish recipes:
Watch the video below where Rachel will walk you through every step of this recipe. Sometimes it helps to have a visual, and we’ve always got you covered with our cooking show. You can find the complete collection of recipes on YouTube, Facebook Watch, or our Facebook Page, or right here on our website with their corresponding recipes.
These potatoes are delicious! I’m making them for the second time tomorrow for a church dinner. I made 10 pounds of potatoes last time, and there were just a few bites left! Thank you, Rachel, for sharing your gift!
I will be making these for the first time this weekend. I’m not the best cook so I’m excited to try. Will garlic have any adverse affects with the butter milk? Our family are big garlic people so would love to add some. Thank you.
A little garlic will be delicious!
Quick question : In your creamiest mashed potato recipe can you refrigerate them overnight and then put them in the crockpot to reheat . Would you need more warming up time? The recipes looks delicious . Does the combination of chicken broth and cream make them a more lighter creamy version ? Thank you . Happy Thanksgiving
They would need more time to heat up for sure. The chicken broth gives such a delicious flavor addition to the recipe and the cream cheese makes them extra creamy and decadent!
great, u have the best recipes
I have made so many of your recipes!
Love them!
This is literally the BEST mashed potato recipe out there. Period. You can use Yukon Gold potatoes as well. You can add some onion salt and/or a little garlic salt, too. My family RAVES over them. All other mashed potato recipes have been circularly filed! This is the only recipe I use, now!
I found this recipe while searching for a dish that would use buttermilk as I had some left over. While I didn’t add the cream cheese, the result was still scrumptious! Boiling the potatoes in chicken broth is the key.
Yours is the only recipe post I follow❣️
Praying for you Rachael ❣️
Love this recipe! I love mashed potatoes!
I cut the recipe down .5, added sour cream [half of cream cheese] used 2%milk and the result was delicious.
Thanks for the idea.
I was wondering if there is a “sour” taste from the cream cheese and buttermilk? I love that flavor (similar to Funeral Potatoes) but my husband’s family does not like the tang or flavor?
This was by far the best mashed potatoes I ever had. Made the day before and warmed up in crockpot. I was never a fan of mashed potatoes until now.
Hubby made these for Thanksgiving after seeing this recipe in your cookbook and kept them warm in a crockpot. It was the best mashed potatoes I’ve ever had. So creamy and flavorful. We both love your recipes!