Homemade Pierogi are stuffed with a flavorful potato and cheese mixture, boiled, and fried up in melted butter for a delicious, indulgent, total comfort food dinner.

A plate of Potato and Cheese Pierogis with sour cream and topped with freshly chopped chives

Pierogies are a classic Polish comfort food dish. In this recipe I’ve taken all of the elements of a classic pierogi and simplified them for the average home cook. While this dish takes time to make, it is overall fairly simple. A quick homemade dough requires some rolling out which is where most of your time will be spent, but it’s fairly simple and a good item to make with children, or as a family. Many hands make light work.

Pierogi can be filled with various fillings, but tradition is a potato and cheese curd mixture. In this recipe we use mashed potatoes and cheddar cheese. Feel free to experiment and use your favorite cheese. Leftover mashed potatoes work really well in this recipe, but you can always make them from scratch specifically for filling. Most grocery stores carry frozen or refrigerated mashed potatoes or you can buy them at the deli counter if you are short on time.

A plate of Potato and Cheese Pierogis with sour cream and topped with freshly chopped chives

What is good to eat with pierogies?

A simple, traditional topping is simple sour cream and maybe some chopped chives. You can also serve pierogies up topped with caramelized onions, paprika, fried sage, or Polish sausage.

What kind of sauce goes on pierogies?

For classic potato filled pierogi, a simple sauce of melted or browned butter is the sauce of choice. If you choose other filling options in your pierogi, like spinach, a light garlic yogurt sauce pairs well.

What do you serve with pierogies?

Roasted vegetables are always a great option to serve with pierogies. You could try some roasted broccoli or serve them up with some roasted simple honey roasted brussel sprouts. You also can’t go wrong with some simple green beans.

A plate of Potato and Cheese Pierogis with sour cream and topped with freshly chopped chives with a bite taken out of one

Can I freeze these?

Yes! You can freeze these pierogies after they have been assembled. And boil them from frozen when you are ready to eat. To freeze, simply place your pierogies in a single layer on a parchment lined baking sheet. Make sure they aren’t touching so that they don’t stick together. Once frozen, remove from the freezer and transfer to a resealable plastic bag for long term storage.

PRO TIP: The key to homemade pierogi is to be sure to seal it shut so that none of the stuffing comes out during cooking. Don’t let any of the filling get in between the dough edges or you won’t be able to get a good seal. Pinch the dough shut with your fingers and then press with the tongs of a fork to further seal and give a decorative edge.

Watch the video below where I walk you through every step of this recipe. Sometimes it helps to have a visual and I’ve got you covered, including how to roll, stuff, and seal your pierogi. You can find my full collection of video recipes on YouTube.

Potato and Cheese Pierogi