These Chocolate Turtle Cookies are ultra decadent, soft, and delicious. Any chocolate lover will go crazy for this delicious cookie recipe!
The chocolate cookie base in this recipe is an incredible mix between a brownie and a cookie. It’s decadently divine if I do say so myself. Add in some chopped pecans and top it all off with a caramel drizzle and you have one decadent cookie that any chocolate lover will go crazy over. I’m telling you, these might be my new favorite cookie!
You can use unwrapped caramel candies in this recipe (as show in the photos) or you can use caramel bits. Caramel bits are little round bits of caramel that are easily melted. I’ve noticed that sometimes you can only find these in your grocery store during the fall–holiday baking season–so be on the lookout!
If you want to make it clear that there are nuts in these cookies, I recommend placing some halved pecans right on top in a decorative fashion. Not only will this be a clear indicator of nuts (which keeps my children at bay), it also adds a bit of style to them.
The price of nuts is always fluctuating. You can easily substitute walnuts in this recipe for a similarly delicious cookie treat. I guess they won’t technically be “turtle” cookies at that point, but your secret is safe with me!
These cookies should be stored in an airtight container once cooled. Be sure to cool the cookies completely before storing. The cookies should be stored in one layer to prevent the caramel from being transferred off the tops and onto the bottoms of other cookies. You can easily do this in a plastic bag, or you can use a tupperware container.
Watch the video below where I walk you through every step of this sinfully delicious recipe. It’ll have you drooling in no time! I like to give you a visual reference point, but in this case, it really should come with a drool warning!
I never comment on recipe websites, but these cookies are worth the time. These are probably the best cookies I’ve ever made, after sharing with my family and friends I already have requests for more cookies. I followed the directions exactly and they turned out perfect.
Yay! I’m so glad you liked them. I totally agree with you, these things are dangerously good!
Can’t wait to try these we are a nut free home what do I have to add to eliminate nuts
You can simply omit the pecans in this recipe to make it nut free.
My family and I love them! These were a huge hit. They came out super thick and fudgy like a brownie. I stuffed the cookies with caramel instead of drizzling the caramel. So good. This is a keeper recipe for sure. 😋
These cookies are so decadent! Awesome!
OMG I have made the bomb cookies
I have Celiac Disease. Can I make these using a gluten free all purpose flour? Thank you.
Worth a try using a 1:1 blend designed for replacing all purpose flour.
This recipe works perfectly every time ? so yummy and they stay moist for so long! Looking forward to impressing the family at a Christmas party tomorrow. I even managed to make 26 cookies! I usually make a lot less than what recipes say, but these cookies are still a great size! Thanks for a wonderful recipe!
They are great.
What are the ingredient measurements in cups, etc ???
Both American and metric measurements are listed above in the recipe. The default is cups.
Do these freeze well?
Yes they do!
i couldn’t wait to try this recipe! They’re smelling amazing in the oven but they’re still in the shape of a ball and haven’t flattened out! What could I have done wrong? I feel like I followed the recipe to a T. We’ll see how they taste 🙂
Don’t worry, thicker cookies stay in a ball for quite some time in the oven but end up turning cookie shaped right near the end 🙂
So happy I came across this. I bake all of the Italian cookies for christmas every year and I always add some form of a new cookie and I have now found it. Two questions. Can you make these smaller as in 1 tbl size. Feel the 2 tbl would be to big for cookie trays and how long do you think they would stay fresh if they are in zip lock bags or good tupperware?
Yes, you can make smaller cookies. They are best when eaten within 3-5 days.
Can you use margarine? I have a lactose child and butter makes her sick
Yes, the texture will just be slightly different.
Looks delicious!! I’am gonna try them today!!
Can this recipe be made without cocoa powder ? The same receipe just minus cocoa powder ?
Not sure what that would be like but it is worth a try! You can replace the cocoa powder with cornstarch to keep the right balance of ingredients.
Anxious to try these, the churros, & the garlic shrimp! Thx
the recipe calls for 14 UNWRAPPED caramels.and the recipes goes as—-Meanwhile, place unwrapped caramels and heavy cream into a microwave safe bowl. Place in the
microwave for 30 seconds. Stir, and microwave again for 30 seconds. Continue until caramel is
completely melted and smooth.
would you not unwrap the caramel BEFORE you micro wave them ….
Unwrapped means without the plastic covering. So you’d definitely place the unwrapped caramels without the plastic covering on them anymore into the microwave.